At ECU, social justice protest is the only speech allowed

UPDATE (October 16, 2020): SLF sent a third letter to ECU today in anticipation of an upcoming Board of Trustees meeting on November 5. SLF reminded the Board that ECU students need to know where the University stands regarding their First Amendment rights. "The Board will no doubt be making major decisions about the spring semester during this meeting," says SLF Attorney Cece O'Leary. "They must address the concerns of ECU students. Students need to know that ECU will value their freedom of expression no matter what, and that the University is taking the necessary steps to do so."

UPDATE (September 24, 2020): Today SLF sent a follow up letter to ECU requesting more clarity about its COVID policies. "ECU went virtual for the remainder of the fall semester, but students are already planning ahead for the spring. A lack of communication about what faces students when they return to campus in January will influence their decision to return to campus at all," warns SLF General Counsel Kim Hermann.

In the letter, SLF listed over a dozen examples of speech activities students want to engage in upon their return. It demanded that the University address how it would handle each scenario so that students can prepare for the spring.

GREENVILLE, NC (September 16, 2020): At East Carolina University (ECU), hundreds of student athletes, coaches, and members of the faculty and staff gathered on campus for a protest. The only problem: ECU has banned all gatherings over 50 people. So why are some students allowed to exercise their First Amendment rights, but not others?

SLF posed this question today in a demand letter to the University. In the letter, SLF seeks clarification about ECU’s COVID policies, especially when it comes to student speech. ECU has punished nearly 20 students for violating social distancing and gathering policies. But when dozens of students protested racial inequality, ECU looked the other way.

“This is blatant viewpoint discrimination in violation of the First Amendment,” states SLF General Counsel Kim Hermann. “A university can’t stifle speech in some ways while promoting it in others. All students have a right to engage in civil discourse.”

SLF pointed out that by taking a position in favor of the student protest, the University has unconstitutionally chilled the expression of other students. ECU has drawn a line in the sand about the speech it will tolerate, and it has shown that any other views are unwelcome.

Want to read more about SLF's efforts to combat discriminatory COVID policies at ECU?

Click here for the Campus Reform article.

Click here for The College Fix article.

234 views0 comments